Private Passions: The Contemplation of Suffering in Medieval Affective Devotions

Private Passions: The Contemplation of Suffering in Medieval Affective Devotions

We are searching data for your request:

Forums and discussions:
Manuals and reference books:
Data from registers:
Wait the end of the search in all databases.
Upon completion, a link will appear to access the found materials.

Private Passions: The Contemplation of Suffering in Medieval Affective Devotions

By Susan M. Arvay

PhD Dissertation, Rutgers University, 2008

Abstract: This dissertation examines the representation of suffering in medieval affective devotional texts. Images of physical and emotional suffering from Christ’s life and Passion abound in these materials meant for private meditation. Critical assessments of this suffering often cast it as indicative of child-like literalism and sentimentality. By contrast, I argue that these texts require the reader to engage with this suffering in far more complex psychological ways.

Chapter one explores the connection between imagined suffering and the ethical function of affective meditations. Drawing on Mary Caruthers’s work on the cultural meanings and uses of memory, I demonstrate how the classical art of memory evolved during the Middle Ages from a secular tool for orators into a Christian tool for self-fashioning.

Chapter two examines the process of self-transformation encouraged by the Meditations on the Life of Christ and questions the perception that the Meditations merely offers a script for a meditator to passively follow in order to feel compassion for Christ. I use performance theory to argue that the Meditations instead relies on a productive tension between pleasure and pain that causes the meditator to experience the act of inflicting emotional pain upon herself as a pleasurable act of self-creation.

Chapter three employs Emmanuel Levinas’s ideas about the nature of an ethical relationship with the Other to illuminate the nature of Margery Kempe’s relationship to Christ in The Book of Margery Kempe. Kempe’s Book demonstrates the necessity to the affective project of failing to make God and his suffering “familiar” to the reader.

Chapter four uses Caroline Bynum’s work on gender in medieval spirituality to argue that the Quis dabit, one of the most popular and influential texts in the planctus Mariae genre, embodies assumptions about gendered spiritual roles that affect how male and female readers relate to Christ and Mary. In the Quis dabit‘s conversation between Bernard of Clairvaux and Mary, Bernard’s attempt to identify with Mary’s suffering turns into his appropriation of Mary’s own narrative in order to make her better fit the “feminine” role that he needs her to play for his own spiritual ends.

Watch the video: Pietà and Lamentation: Themes of Compassion in Cummer Collection (July 2022).


  1. Coley

    In my opinion, you admit the mistake. I offer to discuss it. Write to me in PM.

  2. Helaku

    Not to everybody. I know.

  3. Maximus

    definitely, we will go in and read!

  4. Groshura

    the incomparable message, I like very much :)

  5. Gabriel

    What an interesting phrase

  6. Aymon

    Somehow it won't sink

Write a message